Monday, October 21, 2002

 

State Flags, Day 5


And the lame-o flags just keep on coming ...

MASSACHUSETTS



White field with state coat of arms in center. Coat of arms features a Native American with bow and arrow and a white star. Scroll around flag reads "Ense Petit Placidam Sub Libertate Quietem," or "By the Sword We Seek Peace, but Peace Only Under Liberty."

  • Visual Appeal: 3
    Violates the First and Second Laws, but the lack of garish colors and a fairly simple coat of arms limits the damage.
  • Significance: 3
    The Massachuset Indian is OK, but it's not immediately apparent that it's MA. The arm and sword above the shield goes well with the motto.
  • Recognition: 3
    You'd probably guess that it's one of the 13 colonies, but nothing really distinguishes it as Massachusetts.
  • Reproducability: 4
    Easier than some others.
  • Overall: 13
    A minuteman instead of a Native American would work much better.



    MICHIGAN



    Blue field with a coat of arms in the center. A moose and elk flank a blue shield that reads "TUEBOR" and pictures an armed man overlooking a sunrise over a lake. A bald eagle sits atop shield, and a red scroll reading "E PLURIBUS UNUM" is above. Below the shield is a ribbon reading "SI QUAERIS PENINSULAM AMCENAM CIRCUMSPICE."

  • Visual Appeal: 0
    Busy. Busy, busy, busy, busy. A moose AND an elk? Three instances of words? Detailed figures to the max? Argh!
  • Significance: 2
    Supposedly the moose and elk are symbols of Michigan. News to me ...
  • Recognition: 2
    Really not much to signify Michigan to other Americans.
  • Reproducability: 1
    Please.
  • Overall: 5
    Whoa. Lowest score straight up.



    MINNESOTA



    Deep blue field with state seal in the center. Seal features a farmer and Native American surrounded by a wreath with three dates: 1819, 1858, and 1893. Outer circle of seal depicts 19 stars and "MINNESOTA."

  • Visual Appeal: 2
    Very busy, though the figures aren't that detailed.
  • Significance: 4
    The dates refer to Minnesota history, as do the farmer and Native American. The wreath features the state flower, so that's OK>
  • Recognition: 5
    Standard "Hi, my name is ... " score.
  • Reproducability: 2
    Small, crowded seal.
  • Overall: 13
    Pretty boring.



    MISSISSIPPI



    Horizontal tricolor of red, white, and blue. CSA battle flag in the union square.

  • Visual Appeal: 5
    Many object to the CSA battle flag. I don't mind it, but I have to acknowledge the controversy. Objectively, though, it's a nice, crisp design.
  • Significance: 4
    Very obviously a southern state, though it doesn't really delineate MS.
  • Recognition: 5
    With the demise of GA's old flag, the only one with the actual CSA battle flag left.
  • Reproducability: 8
    Pretty easy.
  • Overall: 22
    The Confederate controversy knocks it down. Would probably be a 25, otherwise.



    MISSOURI



    Horizontal tricolor of red, white, and blue. State seal in center surrounded by anouter blue band with 24 white stars. Seal features two grizzly bears and a lot of other crap. Check the link for a better description of the seal.

  • Visual Appeal: 4
    Seal with words and detailed figures knocks it down.
  • Significance: 4
    Twenty-fourth state. Date of admission. Grizzly bears????
  • Recognition: 4
    Somewhat well-known, but the bears will throw you off. Since when did MO have bears?
  • Reproducability: 4
    Seal is a toughie.
  • Overall: 16
    Show Me a better seal!


  • Comments: Post a Comment



    << Home

    This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?